Bottom line: Which one is better?
Bottom line: Asana is better.
Asana is a better project management than Basecamp when we compare Asana vs Basecamp mainly because it is being geared more for larger companies as well as enterprise users hence it has more end-to-end business solutions like milestones and portfolio view.
Asana vs Basecamp: FEATURES
The features of Asana include task management and project tracking whereby it benefits teams for knowing what each member is doing at what time and when. Its tools simplify and automate many actions required when creating, assigning as well as updating tasks and other given work items of the team. It has got the PM app which is essential in providing multiple views so that users can have various perspectives as well as insight while observing their projects or business progress. In addition, users can customize the default settings as they desire while adding functions so as it can match their expectations. It has ready-made templates to make your setting easy and fast and mobile apps.
Basecamp on the other hand is amongst the earliest project management tools launched in 1999 and is a simple task management, project organization and collaboration software that is designed to promote transparency and communication for the members of the project team to have humble time accessing and sharing files, discuss ideas and even getting updates without being distracted or disturbed from performing their tasks.
Bottom line: both Asana and Basecamp offer the same features.
Asana vs Basecamp: WORK MANAGEMENT
Asana is project management software that is aimed at tracking your project. Each project is first displayed in a list format whereby each list represents a specific task with each task having a status, due date and the person the task is assigned to. It also has an in-built calendar which is related to each project giving managers easy time to tab on task deadlines and note if there is any scheduling mismatch.
Basecamp on the other hand has six core tools for every project which include to-do lists that tracks tasks, message board for announcements and updates purpose, campfire chat tool for users to discuss a given item in the project, schedule tool used top track milestones and as well as deadlines, the docs and files tool that help users to access files required and then lastly the automatic check-ins feature which its work is to automatically ask users for status update on a daily, weekly or on a frequent basis set by the manager.
Bottom line: Asana is better as it is fairly task-based.
Asana vs Basecamp: COLLABORATION
Asana is task-based project management software that allows you to add a lot of information to each task and then arrange them into projects. The custom field tracking and tagging feature allows you to follow and search anything included in your task and has workflow feature that helps you to automate your process. Asana promotes collaboration as it creates a platform for users to communicate at ease with team members within the software.
Basecamp on the other hand has a text editor whereby every member in the project can collaborate on the document that is written in the text editor segment. The action isn’t in real-time, however there’s version control and comments whereby you will be updated when to work on the document. In addition, users can copy documents to other segments as well as duplicate them across projects which are a bit cumbersome. Basecamp offers a platform of tools where team members can communicate and collaborate around tasks as well as ideas like message boards, campfire chat and check-in.
Bottom line: both Asana and Basecamp offer the same collaboration features.
Asana vs Basecamp: PRICING
In terms of pricing, Asana has several editions that can match your preference. We have the free edition for up to 15 members that include task management features and views, premium plan which is a paid plan of $9.99 per user per month billed annually with added features and the business plan that goes at $19.99 per user per month billed annually. There the enterprise plan which is available upon request.
Basecamp pricing is simple and very attractive which is $99 per month that includes unlimited users with all features included and 500GB storage space. In addition, it offers free 30-day trial period.
Bottom line: Basecamp is better.
A comparison of basecamp vs Asana is a bit tricky to decide but Asana is better as it is flexible for project teams as well as individual contributors and is highly task-based.