Bottom line: which one is better?
They being products of competitive companies, Google and Samsung, complicate distinguishing between Google pixel XL vs Samsung s8. The pixel XL does not support expandable memory while s8 takes up to 256GB. On the other hand, the s8 has a large internal memory of 64GB unlike pixel XL at 32GB.
Bottom line: A phone with a large internal memory and supports an expandable memory is better. In this case, s8 has a large memory thus a better phone.
Google Pixel XL vs Samsung Galaxy S8: Design
The difference in comparing pixel XL vs s8 in the design aspect is that s8 is 0.5mm slimmer, 13grams lighter and 5.8mm shorter. To add to that, the s8 comes in 3 extra shades of color as compared to pixel XL granting a range of choices.
Bottom line: a slim, light and shorter phone enhances portability. In this perspective, S8 is better.
Google Pixel XL vs Samsung Galaxy S8: Display
The s8 has a higher pixel density of 568ppi while pixel XL has 534ppi. Additionally the s8 has a difference of screen to body ratio of 13.53%. In looking at s8 vs pixel XL you find that s8 has a screen size of 5.8 inches (14.73 cm) while XL is on 5.5 inches (13.97 cm).
Bottom line: owning a phone with wider screen and large screen to body ratio is impressive. A high pixel density qualifies s8 to be a better phone.
Google Pixel XL vs Samsung Galaxy S8: Performance
The performance of galaxy s8 vs pixel XL on chipset is that s8 has Samsung Exynos 9 Octa 8895 while pixel XL has Qualcomm Snapdragon 821 MSM8996 Pro. Both phones have RAM of 4GB but the graphics differ by s8 having Mali-G71 MP20 and pixel XL having Adreno 530.
Bottom line: Considering the strength and the performance of the phone, the s8 is superior and better.
Google Pixel XL vs Samsung Galaxy S8: Cameras
Despite the fact that both Samsung galaxy s8 vs google pixel XL have high video recording ability of 1920×1080 @ 30 fps, the pixel XL has a difference of physical aperture of F0.7. The pixel XL has sensor of Exmor-R CMOS image while s8 has Exmor-RS CMOS Sensor.
Bottom line: Image capturing becomes easier when you have a high camera resolution and a camera sensor. This makes s8 a better phone.
Google Pixel XL vs Samsung Galaxy S8: Audio
Nothing much to discuss on the audio perspective since both lack FM radio but have loudspeaker as well as an audio jack of 3.5mm.
Bottom line: The similarity in this feature still proves that s8 is more efficient thus a better phone.
Google Pixel XL vs Samsung Galaxy S8: Battery
Contrary to the fact that both phones have a fast charging rate, the pixel XL has a difference in the charging capacity and talk time of up to 450mAh and 12hours on 3G over s8.
Bottom line: A phone with a higher charge capacity is always a goal to have. To add to that, having a high talk time is more admirable. This makes iPhone pixel XL a better phone.
Google Pixel XL vs Samsung Galaxy S8: Special features
The pixel XL has a back fingerprint sensor while s8 has rear sensor position. The s8 has a dual SIM with SIM1 Nano and SIM2 Nano Hybrid while pixel XL has a single SIM with SIM1 Nano.
Bottom line: The essence of having dual SIM is good because you can choose which one to use. This shows s8 is a better phone.
Comparing google pixel XL vs galaxy s8 has been challenging due to their competing features. However, The Samsung Galaxy s8 has shown its superiority as elaborated in the piece and therefore it qualifies to be the better phone to go for.